CARINA Adjustments

Cruise Info

Annotations for this cruise:

View 0 annotation(s) (Lists all annotations)

Files for Adjustment Plot files re. Cruise:

Filename:	Comment:	Action…
RC_SO.png	[autogenerated from RC_Toste/adjustments!]	View
manualXovers.png	[autogenerated from manual_xovers/adjustments!]	View

Data files re. Cruise: - no files! -

Plot/Data files re. Parameter(s) (select parameter on left side to view!):
alkalinity:1 cruise:2 tco2:1

Plot files re. Cluster: - no files! -

Comments re. this cruise in CARINA

View 21 comment(s) (Lists all comments)

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 0.999
(+/-0.020).
12 cross overs show no significant differences (<1%) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no offset in oxygen. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.999
(+/-0.006). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the regional analysis above I suggest no adjustment for oxygen.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 21:29:01 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed, but 1 is discarded due to large uncertainty (with
cruise 74DI19950106). The average of the 14 considered cross overs is 1.039
(+/-0.085).
3 reliable cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
silicate show offsets between 1.02 and 1.06. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises as well as the suggested natural variability in Antarctic deep
waters are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.055
(+/-0.016). This suggests that an adjustment of 0.95 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 0.95 for silicate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 21:23:19 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
8 cross overs were analyzed, but 2 are discarded due to large variability (with
cruises 35MF19930123 and 74DI19950106). The average of the 6 considered cross
overs is 1.026 (+/-0.029).
The 3 cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
nitrate show ratios of 1.03-1.04. When the offset suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.033
(+/-0.013).This suggests that an adjustment of 0.97 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 0.97 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 20:51:55 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 0.973
(+/-0.050).
The 5 cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
nitrate show offsets between 0.95 and 0.98. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.960
(+/-0.036). The large uncertainty attached to this estimate is due to the
scatter of the offsets obtained from cross overs found at 56°S, which could be
attributed to natural variability in Antarctic deep waters. It should be noted
however that the 6 cross overs involving cruises conducted in the subtropical
region less than 10 years after INDIGO3 show a smaller offset (0.979 +/-0.007),
which suggests that an adjustment of 1.02 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 1.02 for nitrate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 20:36:57 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
9 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +10.0 (+/-6.7)
umol/kg.
2 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 umol/kg) and involve cruises
that are thought to have no offset in alkalinity. This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
Interestingly, the other 7 cross overs show offsets increasing with time: from
-5 umol/kg over a 9 years-period (with cruise 320619960503) to -17 umol/kg over
a 17 years-period (with cruise 35MF20040103). The dependence with time suggests
that the differences observed could reflect natural changes.
CONCLUSION:
Based on this I suggest no adjustment for alkalinity, in good agreement with
GLODAP.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco
INDIGO3 - tco2

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 13:53:06 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 1.008 (+/-0.006) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is thought to have no offset in oxygen. This
suggests that a small adjustment could be required.
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over with cruise 49NZ20031209 (BEAGLE Leg 5) suggests that a
small adjustment could be required for oxygen, but the evidence is insufficient
to conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:24:42 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 1.021 (+/-0.020) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in silicate. It
should be noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly lower offset
(<2%).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with 49NZ20031209) suggests that a small
adjustment could be required for silicate, but the evidence is insufficient to
conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:14:48 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 0.994 (+/-0.019) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in phosphate. It
should be noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly larger offset
(0.98-0.99).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with cruise 49NZ20031209) suggests that a
small adjustment could be required for phosphate, but the evidence is
insufficient to conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:05:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 0.957 (+/-0.014) compared
to cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in nitrate. It should be
noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly larger offset (around
0.95).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with cruise 49NZ20031209) suggests that
an adjustment could be required (about 1.05), but the evidence is insufficient
to conclude.
No suggestion.

___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:50:08 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of +3.1 (+/-1.8) umol/kg
with cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have low alkalinity values by about
10 umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of +7 umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the only one cross over with cruise 49NZ20031209 I suggest an
adjustment of +7 umol/kg for alkalinity, in good agreement with the correction
proposed in GLODAP (+6.8 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:28:29 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
11 cross overs were analyzed, but 6 are discarded because they are based on 1
deep measurement only (OISO cruises). The average of the 5 considered cross
overs is 0.995 (+/-0.021).
3 cross overs show no significant differences (<1%) and involve cruises that are
thought to have no offset in oxygen. When the offsets suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of the 5 considered cross overs is
1.002 (+/-0.005). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for oxygen.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:20:32 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
12 cross overs were analyzed, but 1 is discarded due to large uncertainty (with
cruise 35MF20000117). The average of the 11 considered cross overs is 0.987
(+/-0.033).
Only 2 cross overs show no significant differences (<2%) and involve cruises
that are thought to have no offset in silicate. When the offsets suggested for
the other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.992
(+/-0.07).This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for silicate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:19:55 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
4 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 1.018 (+/-0.011).
All cross overs show a positive offset, ranging from 1.007 to 1.031. The larger
number results from comparison with cruise 74DI19940219 which is thought to have
low nitrate values. When the offset suggested for cruise 74DI19940219 is taken
into account the average of all cross overs is 1.016 (+/-0.06).This suggests
that a small adjustment could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of 0.98 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:19:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
11 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 1.002
(+/-0.026).
4 cross overs show no significant differences (<2%) and involve cruises that are
thought to have no offset in nitrate. When the offsets suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.009
(+/-0.06).This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for nitrate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:18:28 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
8 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +16.1 (+/-3.8)
umol/kg.
All cross overs show significant differences, ranging from +7.8 to +19.8
umol/kg, and 6 of them involve cruises that are thought to have no offset in
alkalinity. When the offsets suggested for the other cruises are taken into
account the average of all cross overs is +15.8 (+/-2.8) umol/kg. This suggests
that an adjustment of -16 umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -16 umol/kg for alkalinity, in disagreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-6.5 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:17:38 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of -0.3 (+/-4.6) ppm
(with cruise 49NZ20031209). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:32:54 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is -0.5 (+/-7.5)
ppm.
10 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 ppm) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no significant offset in salinity .This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:32:31 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
12 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +4.7 (+/-5.1)
umol/kg.
All cross overs but 1 show significant differences ranging from 4.3 to 13.3
umol/kg. When the suggested offsets are taken into account the average of all
cross overs is +5.5 (+/-0.7) umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of -5.5
umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -5.5 umol/kg for TCO2, in good agreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-6.4 umol/kg).

___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:31:50 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of +2.0 (+/-3.0) umol/kg
(with cruise 49NZ20031209). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on only 1 cross over (with cruise 49NZ20031209) I suggest no adjustment
for TCO2, in disagreement with the correction proposed in GLODAP (-9.4 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:31:13 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
8 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +10.4 (+/-3.7)
umol/kg.
All cross overs show significant differences, ranging from +5.2 to +15.7
umol/kg. When the suggested offsets are taken into account the average of all
cross overs is +10.3 (+/-1.3) umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of -10.3
umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -10.3 umol/kg for TCO2, in good agreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-10.7 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:28:20 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
12 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is -2.1 (+/-7.9)
ppm.
10 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 ppm) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no significant offset in salinity. This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:27:41 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

View other postings and files re. this adjustment

ReadMe file(s) for this cruise

View 0 ReadMe(s) (Lists all ReadMes)

Files and Comments for salinity

Files

Plot files re. Salinity
[+]: - no files! -

Data files re. Salinity
[+]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by salinity in subject)

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of -0.3 (+/-4.6) ppm
(with cruise 49NZ20031209). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:32:54 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is -0.5 (+/-7.5)
ppm.
10 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 ppm) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no significant offset in salinity .This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:32:31 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - salinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
12 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is -2.1 (+/-7.9)
ppm.
10 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 ppm) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no significant offset in salinity. This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for salinity.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:27:41 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for ctd_salinity

Files

Plot files re. CTD-Sal. [+]
adj. - slope/intercept - action [ID]: - no files! -

Data files re. CTD-Sal. [+]
adj. - slope/intercept - action [ID]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by ctd_salinity in subject)

Files and Comments for tco2

Files

Plot files re. TCO₂
[+]:

Filename:	Comment:	Action…
offset__tco2_stdr_plot_INDIGO_11044.png	IIM-CSIC inversions result plot	View

Data files re. TCO₂
[+]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by tco2 in subject)

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
12 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +4.7 (+/-5.1)
umol/kg.
All cross overs but 1 show significant differences ranging from 4.3 to 13.3
umol/kg. When the suggested offsets are taken into account the average of all
cross overs is +5.5 (+/-0.7) umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of -5.5
umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -5.5 umol/kg for TCO2, in good agreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-6.4 umol/kg).

___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:31:50 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of +2.0 (+/-3.0) umol/kg
(with cruise 49NZ20031209). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on only 1 cross over (with cruise 49NZ20031209) I suggest no adjustment
for TCO2, in disagreement with the correction proposed in GLODAP (-9.4 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:31:13 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - tco2

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
8 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +10.4 (+/-3.7)
umol/kg.
All cross overs show significant differences, ranging from +5.2 to +15.7
umol/kg. When the suggested offsets are taken into account the average of all
cross overs is +10.3 (+/-1.3) umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of -10.3
umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -10.3 umol/kg for TCO2, in good agreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-10.7 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-05 20:28:20 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for alkalinity

Files

Plot files re. Alkalinity
[+]:

Filename:	Comment:	Action…
ps.out.0001.pdf		View

Data files re. Alkalinity
[+]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by alkalinity in subject)

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
9 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +10.0 (+/-6.7)
umol/kg.
2 cross overs show no significant differences (<5 umol/kg) and involve cruises
that are thought to have no offset in alkalinity. This suggests that no
adjustment would be required.
Interestingly, the other 7 cross overs show offsets increasing with time: from
-5 umol/kg over a 9 years-period (with cruise 320619960503) to -17 umol/kg over
a 17 years-period (with cruise 35MF20040103). The dependence with time suggests
that the differences observed could reflect natural changes.
CONCLUSION:
Based on this I suggest no adjustment for alkalinity, in good agreement with
GLODAP.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco
INDIGO3 - tco2

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 13:53:06 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a difference of +3.1 (+/-1.8) umol/kg
with cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have low alkalinity values by about
10 umol/kg. This suggests that an adjustment of +7 umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the only one cross over with cruise 49NZ20031209 I suggest an
adjustment of +7 umol/kg for alkalinity, in good agreement with the correction
proposed in GLODAP (+6.8 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:28:29 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - alkalinity

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
8 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is +16.1 (+/-3.8)
umol/kg.
All cross overs show significant differences, ranging from +7.8 to +19.8
umol/kg, and 6 of them involve cruises that are thought to have no offset in
alkalinity. When the offsets suggested for the other cruises are taken into
account the average of all cross overs is +15.8 (+/-2.8) umol/kg. This suggests
that an adjustment of -16 umol/kg could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of -16 umol/kg for alkalinity, in disagreement with the
correction proposed in GLODAP (-6.5 umol/kg).
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:17:38 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for ph

Files

Plot files re. pH
[+]: - no files! -

Data files re. pH
[+]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by ph in subject)

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
8 cross overs were analyzed, but 2 are discarded due to large variability (with
cruises 35MF19930123 and 74DI19950106). The average of the 6 considered cross
overs is 1.026 (+/-0.029).
The 3 cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
nitrate show ratios of 1.03-1.04. When the offset suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.033
(+/-0.013).This suggests that an adjustment of 0.97 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 0.97 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 20:51:55 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 0.994 (+/-0.019) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in phosphate. It
should be noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly larger offset
(0.98-0.99).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with cruise 49NZ20031209) suggests that a
small adjustment could be required for phosphate, but the evidence is
insufficient to conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:05:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
4 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 1.018 (+/-0.011).
All cross overs show a positive offset, ranging from 1.007 to 1.031. The larger
number results from comparison with cruise 74DI19940219 which is thought to have
low nitrate values. When the offset suggested for cruise 74DI19940219 is taken
into account the average of all cross overs is 1.016 (+/-0.06).This suggests
that a small adjustment could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of 0.98 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:19:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for pco2

Files

Plot files re. pCO₂
[+]: - no files! -

Data files re. pCO₂
[+]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by pco2 in subject)

Files and Comments for nitrate

Files

Plot files re. Nitrate
[x]: - no files! -

Data files re. Nitrate
[x]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by nitrate in subject)

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 0.973
(+/-0.050).
The 5 cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
nitrate show offsets between 0.95 and 0.98. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.960
(+/-0.036). The large uncertainty attached to this estimate is due to the
scatter of the offsets obtained from cross overs found at 56°S, which could be
attributed to natural variability in Antarctic deep waters. It should be noted
however that the 6 cross overs involving cruises conducted in the subtropical
region less than 10 years after INDIGO3 show a smaller offset (0.979 +/-0.007),
which suggests that an adjustment of 1.02 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 1.02 for nitrate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 20:36:57 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 0.957 (+/-0.014) compared
to cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in nitrate. It should be
noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly larger offset (around
0.95).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with cruise 49NZ20031209) suggests that
an adjustment could be required (about 1.05), but the evidence is insufficient
to conclude.
No suggestion.

___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:50:08 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - nitrate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
11 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 1.002
(+/-0.026).
4 cross overs show no significant differences (<2%) and involve cruises that are
thought to have no offset in nitrate. When the offsets suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.009
(+/-0.06).This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for nitrate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:18:28 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for phosphate

Files

Plot files re. Phosphate
[x]: - no files! -

Data files re. Phosphate
[x]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by phosphate in subject)

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
8 cross overs were analyzed, but 2 are discarded due to large variability (with
cruises 35MF19930123 and 74DI19950106). The average of the 6 considered cross
overs is 1.026 (+/-0.029).
The 3 cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
nitrate show ratios of 1.03-1.04. When the offset suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.033
(+/-0.013).This suggests that an adjustment of 0.97 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 0.97 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 20:51:55 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 0.994 (+/-0.019) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in phosphate. It
should be noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly larger offset
(0.98-0.99).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with cruise 49NZ20031209) suggests that a
small adjustment could be required for phosphate, but the evidence is
insufficient to conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:05:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - phosphate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
4 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 1.018 (+/-0.011).
All cross overs show a positive offset, ranging from 1.007 to 1.031. The larger
number results from comparison with cruise 74DI19940219 which is thought to have
low nitrate values. When the offset suggested for cruise 74DI19940219 is taken
into account the average of all cross overs is 1.016 (+/-0.06).This suggests
that a small adjustment could be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest an adjustment of 0.98 for phosphate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:19:30 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for silicate

Files

Plot files re. Silicate
[x]: - no files! -

Data files re. Silicate
[x]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by silicate in subject)

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed, but 1 is discarded due to large uncertainty (with
cruise 74DI19950106). The average of the 14 considered cross overs is 1.039
(+/-0.085).
3 reliable cross overs involving cruises that are thought to have no offset in
silicate show offsets between 1.02 and 1.06. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises as well as the suggested natural variability in Antarctic deep
waters are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 1.055
(+/-0.016). This suggests that an adjustment of 0.95 could be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the analysis above, I suggest an adjustment of 0.95 for silicate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 21:23:19 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 1.021 (+/-0.020) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is known to have no offset in silicate. It
should be noted, however, that the deepest waters show a slightly lower offset
(<2%).
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over analyzed here (with 49NZ20031209) suggests that a small
adjustment could be required for silicate, but the evidence is insufficient to
conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:14:48 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - silicate

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
12 cross overs were analyzed, but 1 is discarded due to large uncertainty (with
cruise 35MF20000117). The average of the 11 considered cross overs is 0.987
(+/-0.033).
Only 2 cross overs show no significant differences (<2%) and involve cruises
that are thought to have no offset in silicate. When the offsets suggested for
the other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.992
(+/-0.07).This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for silicate.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:19:55 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for oxygen

Files

Plot files re. Oxygen
[x]: - no files! -

Data files re. Oxygen
[x]: - no files! -

View comment(s) (filtered by oxygen in subject)

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO3 (stations 75 to 117)
15 cross overs were analyzed. The average of all cross overs is 0.999
(+/-0.020).
12 cross overs show no significant differences (<1%) and involve cruises that
are thought to have no offset in oxygen. When the offsets suggested for the
other cruises are taken into account the average of all cross overs is 0.999
(+/-0.006). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
Based on the regional analysis above I suggest no adjustment for oxygen.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 21:29:01 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO2 (stations 26 to 74)
Only 1 cross over was analyzed which shows a ratio of 1.008 (+/-0.006) compared
to the cruise 49NZ20031209 which is thought to have no offset in oxygen. This
suggests that a small adjustment could be required.
CONCLUSION:
The only one cross over with cruise 49NZ20031209 (BEAGLE Leg 5) suggests that a
small adjustment could be required for oxygen, but the evidence is insufficient
to conclude.
No suggestion.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 12:24:42 UTC for data product: CARINA

INDIGO - oxygen

GLOBAL ANALYSIS (Cruise plot file: RC_SO):
INDIGO consists of 3 cruises conducted in 1985 (INDIGO1), 1986 (INDIGO2) and
1987 (INDIGO3) that must be analyzed separately.
REGIONAL ANALYSIS: INDIGO1 (stations 1 to 25)
11 cross overs were analyzed, but 6 are discarded because they are based on 1
deep measurement only (OISO cruises). The average of the 5 considered cross
overs is 0.995 (+/-0.021).
3 cross overs show no significant differences (<1%) and involve cruises that are
thought to have no offset in oxygen. When the offsets suggested for the other
cruises are taken into account the average of the 5 considered cross overs is
1.002 (+/-0.005). This suggests that no adjustment would be required.
CONCLUSION:
I suggest no adjustment for oxygen.
___________________
Paris, August 2008
Claire Lo Monaco

Posted by claire.lomonaco@locean.upmc.fr on 2008-10-06 11:20:32 UTC for data product: CARINA

Hide comments

Files and Comments for ctd_oxygen

Files

Plot files re. CTD-Oxyg. [x]
adj. - slope/intercept - action [ID]: - no files! -

Data files re. CTD-Oxyg. [x]
adj. - slope/intercept - action [ID]: - no files! -

Stations:	[1-25]	[26-74]	[75-117]
The selected Calculated Carbon Parameter has been dismissed in October 2017! Legacy values will be exported as is and displayed in red with subscript "c", e.g. -0.123456_c! No data available? Insert -999 No suggestion for adjustment possible? Insert -888 To calibrate CTDsal use: CTDsal_calibrated = (CTDsal - CTDsal_intercept) / CTDsal_slope To calibrate CTDoxy use: CTDoxy_calibrated = (CTDoxy - CTDoxy_intercept) / CTDoxy_slope
Insert your commit message below explaining your change(s) before you save…
Salinity [+]
CTD-Sal. [+] slope/intercept - action [ID]	/ - #
TCO₂ [+]
Alkalinity [+]
pH [+]
pCO₂ [+]
Nitrate [x]
Phosphate [x]
Silicate [x]
Oxygen [x]
CTD-Oxyg. [x] slope/intercept - action [ID]	/ - #
CFC12 [x]
CFC11 [x]
CFC113 [x]
CCl4 [x]
C13 [+]
SF6 [x]

Dataproduct: CARINA :: Adjustments

Cruise: INDIGO (dataset:CARINA) Data product: CARINA

Please wait while loading list of related files…

INDIGO - oxygen

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - oxygen

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - oxygen

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - salinity

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - tco2

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - alkalinity

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - nitrate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - phosphate

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - silicate

INDIGO - oxygen

INDIGO - oxygen

INDIGO - oxygen